[ADDED 21.00 BST: This post has been updated. The BBC story has now been stealth edited to be less misleading and the identity of the singer, who is a US marine, has emerged.]
Commenter Barker John alerted me to this post from LGF.
The BBC story concerned is by Adam Brookes and is called ‘Kill Iraqis marine song’ probe and misplaced quote marks are the least of its problems. It describes a video of a man, apparently a US marine, singing a song about Iraq.
The BBC story is worded to give the impression that the song is about US marines gleefully killing Iraqis, including children.
…apparently shows a serving marine singing about killing Iraqi civilians.
And
Posted on the YouTube website, the video shows a man in uniform strumming a guitar while singing about killing Iraqis, as others laugh and cheer.
And
The lyrics caught on video refer to the shooting of Iraqi civilians, especially children.
These are weasel words. The lyrics do refer to “the shooting” of a child – but by her own father and brother, not by the narrator. The narrator’s first reaction to seeing an Iraqi girl is to fall in love with her. She takes him home to see her family. It turns out to be an ambush.
You can watch and listen for yourself if you follow the link to the LGF post. (Not work safe or suitable for children due to swearing and general tastelessness.)
I cut and pasted the version of the lyrics given by Rayra, making a few changes where I heard things differently or ambiguously.
I was out in the sands of Iraq
And we were under attack
And I, well, I didn’t know where to go.
And the first thing that I could see was
Everybody’s favorite Burger [or Burqua?] King
So I threw open the door and I hit the floor.
Then suddenly to my surprise
I looked up and I saw her eyes
And I knew it was love at first sight.
And she said…
Durka Durka Mohammed Jihad
Sherpa Sherpa Bak Allah [This cartoon Arabic is taken from the film “Team America”.]
Hadji girl I can’t understand what you’re saying.
And she said…
Durka Durka Mohammed Jihad
Sherpa Sherpa Bak Allah
Hadji girl I love you anyway.
Then she said that she wanted me to see.
She wanted me to go meet her family
But I, well, I couldn’t figure out how to say no.
‘Cause I don’t speak Arabic.
So, she took me down an old dirt trail.
And she pulled up to a side shanty
And she threw open the door and I hit the floor.
Cause her brother and her father shouted… [Some LGF commenters thought “shouted” was “shot her”. I heard “shouted.”]
Durka Durka Mohammed Jihad
Sherpa Sherpa Bak Allah
They pulled out their AKs so I could see
And they said…
Durka Durka Mohammed Jihad
Sherpa Sherpa Bak Allah
So I grabbed her little sister and pulled her in front of me.
[This line is timed to be the punch line and one can hear laughter]
As the bullets began to fly
The blood sprayed from between her eyes
And then I laughed maniacally
Then I hid behind the TV
And I locked and loaded my M-16
And I blew those little fuckers to eternity.
And I said…
Durka Durka Mohammed Jihad
Sherpa Sherpa Bak Allah
They should have known they were fucking with a Marine.
This song is insensitive and in poor taste. Soldiers’ songs often are. Twenty years ago two popular songs in the British Army were “Bestiality is Best, Boys” and (to the tune of Camptown Races) “Napalm Burns on a Baby’s Back, Doodah, Doodah.”
In the song, the narrator is described as using the little sister as a human shield in an attempt to stop himself from being shot in ambush. Not exactly in accordance with the highest military tradition, but softened by the fact that that line is obviously meant to surprise by its very ingloriousness. It is the punch line of a black joke.
(AFTERTHOUGHT: The BBC loves to describe its own comedies as “edgy”, meaning “close to the edge of what is permissible” rather than “irritable.”)
Had the BBC been content to report this straight, there would have been a minor story along the same lines as those we have seen about “lads’ culture” or “canteen culture” in the British armed services and police. It could have reported the embarrassment of various Pentagon spokesmen and I’d have said, fair cop. But the BBC, so careful to report the sayings of Jihadists in a sensitive manner, could not resist the chance to selectively quote in such a way as to cause maximum resentment among Muslims.
Another example of bias: the “Bullets began to fly” lines from the lyrics are quoted in the main story and also featured in a quote box. The same quote box has a helpful link to another story called Haditha: Massacre and cover-up? This story has a pair of graphics illustrating two incompatible accounts of the alleged massacre at Haditha. One is labelled “Haditha deaths: US troops’ version” and the other labelled “Haditha deaths: eyewitnesses’ version.” Dunno about you, but I thought this was begging the question.
UPDATE: Hat tip to Mike: the BBC story has now been stealth edited to read “The lyrics caught on video refer to the shooting of Iraqi civilians, especially children, by insurgents and then how a marine responds, opening fire himself.” As is usual with the BBC, the “last updated” field has not been altered.
UPDATE II: DFH provides before and after screenshots of the BBC story and Biodegradable links to an interview with the Marine who made up the song.
Thanks for the hat tip Natalie, as they say over there.
LGF do seem to be nailing the stories, a very tight team on board. I used to find it a touch gung-ho with regards to comments, but I can live with that in the present climate. They are watching the BBC very closely nowdays. Just wish I could join, such infrequent opening times for membership!
0 likes
The BBC really is shameless. I guess they’re hoping nobody bothers to go to YouTube, search for the video, watch the whole thing, make their own minds up.
Much easier to portray the Americans as cold, heartless murderers.
_____
Barker John,
I mananged to get LGF membership. It only opens up for new members at the weekend. I think I signed up on a Saturday afternoon (UK time).
0 likes
American soldiers often sing about killing their enemies during runs etc. In the 1980 documentary “Soldier Girls” a group of recruits to the US Army is seen on a group run and they sing:
I wanna be an airborne ranger,
I wanna live a life of danger,
I wanna go to Iran,
I wanna kill an Iranian
A decade or so earlier the group would have been singing about going to Vietnam and wanting to kill a Viet Cong. None of this is anything new. The songs may be in questionable taste in these PC-obsessed times but, despite what the left-wing media would have you believe, US, UK & Australian troops take great care not to hurt civillians. Recently several politicians have shown concern over rap lyrics glorifying violence and treating women badly, but I haven’t noticed Al Beeb getting all hot and bothered about it.
It’s just another stick with which to bash the military.
0 likes
Can anyone else confirm this or am I incorrectly remembering the orignal BBC story which I looked at around 10:00 today.
news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/americas/5077858.stm
It now says “The lyrics caught on video refer to the shooting of Iraqi civilians, especially children, by insurgents and then how a marine responds, opening fire himself.”
Surely the “by insurgents” bit has been added. But the timestamp for the story hasn’t changed. Can they do that?
0 likes
Mike Davies,
We call it “stealth editing.” Common practice on the part of the BBC.
I’ll post an update on the blog post.
0 likes
Before and after screencaps.
0 likes
This practice of stealth editing of stories on BBC website is so reminiscent of what Winston Smith did at the Ministry of Truth in Orwell’s 1984 that it’s uncanny.
0 likes
The marine in question speaks:
http://www.jacksonvilledailynews.com/SiteProcessor.cfm?Template=/GlobalTemplates/Details.cfm&StoryID=42520&Section=News
0 likes
Funny, I don’t recall the BBC getting so worked up about violent lyrics in rap songs. But then, minorities can do no wrong, US marines can do no right.
0 likes
I made a complaint including a link to the LGF story yesterday morning – maybe I can claim a stealth edit “kill”!
4 more and I’m a B-BBC ace?
0 likes