As David has mentioned the BBC has been particularly fawning about Bob Crow so far….he is presented as a roguish lad with none of the tough realities behind his actions given any credence…..Thatcher was immediately, within minutes of her death, being denounced as divisive and hated, Crow is apparently ‘loved and respected’. Pienaar has been glossing over all the complaints targeted at Crow….his high salary, living in a council house, his holiday as the union was about to strike….Crow was just a loveable rogue.
Ken Livingstone only had nice things to say about him according to the BBC…..
Mr Johnson’s predecessor Ken Livingstone told the BBC the “endless strain of being a media hate figure” may have taken a toll on Mr Crow.
And Crow wasn’t a serious threat to anything he was much misrepresented by those with an agenda….
Mr Crow’s class-based politics made him a regular cartoon villain for some newspapers.
The nearest the BBC comes to the truth is in this ‘Magazine’ article:
Bob Crow, who has died at the age of 52, was an intensively divisive figure. But he was easily the best-known trade unionist in the UK.
To his admirers he was a working-class hero and fighter who stood up for his members and won. To his enemies he was a bully who inflated his workers’ wages by bringing misery upon commuters.
In the eyes of his opponents, Crow’s achievements were gouged by exploiting his position in order to inflict misery on travellers. But to his members it was a testament to his tactical acumen, negotiating skills and mastery of industrial relations.
But such views were not reflected in the news and other coverage as I listened today.
The Telegraph gets the tone about right:
Bob Crow was the belligerent RMT leader whose tough tactics were loved by union members but hated by commuters
He had John Prescott, a former official of the union, expelled for failing to renationalise the railways, then resigned from the board of Transport for London after the exasperated mayor, Ken Livingstone, urged workers to cross the RMT’s latest picket line. In 2004 Labour expelled the RMT from the party.
But what about cuddly Ken, did he always think such nice thoughts about Bob? From the Guardian:
I think that the right to strike is our second most important right after the right to vote. What appals me about the RMT is that by misusing the strike weapon, basically as a bullying technique rather than to resolve a genuine and irreconcilable difference, they undermine that. It certainly would not be right, I don’t think, to impose on people in Unite and the TSSA the loss of their right to strike because a small handful of people on the RMT executive are behaving rather more like a protection racket than a proper industrial union.
Not as if the BBC didn’t know that…from 2009:
Even the former Mayor of London, Ken Livingstone, said in 2007 the RMT executive behaved more like a “protection racket than a proper industrial union”.
So far they have managed to avoid repeating Ken’s previous thoughts today.
An irony is that it may have been privatisation of the railways that gave Crow so much power, the BBC tells us….though he surely would have had more over a nationalised monopoly:
Ralph Darlington, professor of employment relations at Salford University, says the union’s confrontational style can be traced back to rail privatisation.
“I think we could characterise the RMT as one of the most militant and left-wing unions in Britain. The politicisation has come about in the face of the challenges which they feel they have faced.”
What of Crow’s communist ideals?:
“When I see Ronaldo earns half a million quid a month and people say train drivers are greedy working nine hours downstairs in them temperatures – nah, I think it’s the rate for the job. The reality is it’s a jungle out there.”
So its dog eat dog and damn everyone else as long as his union members get their pay rise.
The boy done good but there was a price to pay…..the BBC loved his tough negotiating stance ignoring the threats and just telling us how wonderfully successful his last minute negotiation were…the reality was a bit different, not quite so romantic:
Often his first step was a strike ballot, with negotiations only on the eve of disruption, if then. He once told West End retailers who warned that another Tube strike would put them out of business that they would be “casualties of war”.
Retailers…pah…who needs them…they just feed the greed, materialism and consumerism that is destroying society and the planet. No wonder the BBC likes him.
Nick Robinson at least recognises that Bob has been transformed into a second ‘Saint Bob’…..though he thinks it is more to do with Crow’s admirable belligerence and entrenched opinions rather than what is more likely…the romantic appeal amongst the BBC trots of someone who opposed the Bosses……
Bob Crow: Public enemy number one or national treasure?
No-one, of course, likes to speak ill of the dead but there are other reasons why Bob Crow may appear to have been transformed overnight from public enemy number one to a national treasure.
This was a man who knew what he thought, knew whose side he was on and knew who the enemy were – in an era when that can be said of a shrinking number of people in public life.