The BBC demands a ‘sustainable recovery’ and never mind what recovery there is now you’d better batten down the hatches because it forecasts a grim, depressing future as austerity really bites…you ain’t seen nothing yet….and welfare cuts are impoverishing the demonised poor.
Remarkable how the BBC have totally ignored the wave of criticism that Miliband received, much from his own side, for his abysmal response to the budget……Pienaar and Co’s only reference to the bad performance was to make the excuse ‘Well it must be difficult for the poor lad‘….strangely the same lame excuse Ed Balls muttered.
Never mind this damning look at Miliband’s robot like performance:
No wonder it seemed familiar! How Ed Miliband’s Budget speech recycled the same soundbites he has used for four years
The BBC weren’t so reluctant to step up the attacks when Grant Shapps published his ‘bingo and beer’ response:
Hardly the biggest story of the day…not a story at all really.
However the BBC clearly thought it was, putting it straight onto the frontpage:
Note also that headline….. ‘Chancellor defends pension overhaul’
He defends it does he? So there is something wrong with the scheme? Perhaps he was just ‘explaining’ it.
And as for beer and bingo being ‘patronising’….tell that to the workers:
Budget 2014: What do workers think?
Seems they liked the budget quite a lot.
Yep……We’ve just had the budget….but the BBC laid the groundwork for their narrative that they created and now intend to use, long before Osborne stood up and made his speech.
The BBC has had to develop a new approach to reporting the economy…just as Miliband had to abandon Plan B and has now adopted his ‘living standards crisis’ spiel now that the various double and triple dip recessions haven’t happened, employment keeps on rising, businesses keep reporting good news and inflation is down, and the recovery looks to be on its way, slowly but surely.
The BBC keeps of course trying to undermine the government, rising employment is a ‘puzzle’, or if not, it is the wrong sort of jobs, or the recovery is fragile….all based on consumer spending and borrowing or spending their savings…though no proof of that is ever given.
The basis for their latest approach….demanding proof of a ‘sustainable recovery’. A bit of an amorphous demand….practically unachievable to prove such a thing, the BBC moving the goalposts that would signify success for Osborne….like Miliband’s ‘living standards crisis’ there would never be enough solid evidence that definitively proved anything…which of course is ideal as they can keep spinning out the talk of a ‘fragile, unsustainable’ recovery forever basically…however successful the economy becomes…..they will, and do, point back to the crash and say ‘You might think you’re doing well…but so did they way back then!’.
The second leg to their campaign to undermine Osborne is to say yes things might be improving, for some, but the future is really grim with 5 more years of austerity piling on the pain…..the country can’t take any more!
However, don’t know about you, but I have yet to meet anyone who is really struggling….or struggling more than they would be under any other government and economic regime…most seemed to have weathered the crash quite well….including the ‘vulnerable’ and the poorest.
Here is Peter Allen from a couple of days ago, doing his dead budget sketch telling us that it’s all ‘deeply depressing’ and that ‘most people would think they have been well and truly clobbered…but they ain’t seen nothing yet’.
He tells us that ‘It’s pretty grim….we’ve got several more years of cuts’……austerity is a ‘nonsense…we can’t go on like this.’
Allen rounds off his chat with economist Sarah Hewin from Standard Chartered Bank with a question…..‘Are others [countries] doing it better than us?’…meaning are they running their economy better…..you might be surprised to hear ther UK isn’t doing very well apparently…even Greece is moving ahead faster than us…..of course it is:
This week’s conclusion of months of talks to release €10bn of aid, and a promised return to international bond markets before May, have done nothing to silence critics who say a third bailout will be needed to address the country’s monumental debt problems.
Good old BBC, always trust it to bring us the full picture.
Later in the programme (2 hrs 45) we are taken to hear the views of those involved with the Community Links charity in Newham….a Labour controlled borough.
Community Links is run by Geraldine Blake….who is according to the Guardian, a ‘leading leftwing thinker’.
The presenter [Leslie Ashmall] starts by telling us that the budget brought no surprises [really?]…there wasn’t much in the budget for the poor of Newham…..just more welfare cuts and more local government cuts…and they hurt here, they really do, she tells us.
So you know where she is coming from…..she had a narrative and stuck to it, encouraging those being interviewed to paint the bleakest picture they could of their lives under the Tory yoke.
They responded well to the prodding….telling us that the poor will be getting poorer, they’ll be on the breadline…there’s no investment and no regeneration in the area.
The presenter didn’t bother to ask if that might have been the Labour controlled council that was responsible for that…they have been in power for decades after all.
Is there anything in the budget for people like this the presenter asks Geraldine Blake who replies……Well there’s a bit of tinkering and tweaking but not really…..this government has very successfully demonised a very vulnerable group in society, tarring them with the same brush as fraudsters and shirkers…what we are seeing is that people are pushed away from the job market, the situation is just appalling…a very bad reflection on how we treat the most vulnerable in society.
Pretty much confirmation that she might well be one of the ‘leading leftwing thinkers’ of legend.
Ashmall’s response…‘Yes, I’ve certainly met very many miserable people today.’
The BBC…never mind the millions who might benefit from the budget….just concentrate on the few who may, or may not benefit.