A Biased BBC reader writes…
“A 98 per cent vote in favour of a referendum? That’s a landslide. Alas, for the BBC in its coverage of Hungary’s vote to decline the EU’s plan of handing them hundreds of Muslim migrants, the low turnout (43 per cent) “appeared to render it [the vote] invalid”.
Yes, like Brexit, the results have to be questioned. However, unlike the 48-52 per cent Brexit margin that was deemed too narrow to respect the will of the people, this time the narrative shifts to the “validity” of the vote as only 43 per cent of the Hungarian electorate voted. Apparently, this is short of the 50 per cent required to be “valid”.
Valid? We all know if the Brexit vote went the other way there would be no calls for a second referendum. We all know if Hungary voted 98 per cent on a turnout of 43 per cent to accept the migrants there would be no snide questions about the vote being valid.
How do we know?
Well, Katya Adler mentions in passing President Viktor Orban, who led a “prominent, expensive and relentless anti-EU and anti-migrant referendum campaign but failed to persuade most Hungarians to vote.” In fairness, she does point out that a higher percentage of Hungarians voted against EU migrant quotas than voted for EU membership 13 years ago.
A higher percentage of Hungarians voted against EU migrant quotas than voted for EU membership 13 years ago? Interesting.
I looked up that referendum and it was 84% pro on a 46% turn out. So surely a 46 per cent turnout means that the referendum result, and by dint Hungary’s membership of the EU, is also not valid as it didn’t pass the 50 per cent threshold?
As we know, the Beeb (and the EU) doesn’t work like that. As with this migrant vote and Brexit, when they make every attempt to undermine the outcome if the vote goes against them, when the outcome goes in their favour, questions of legitimacy and democracy are disregarded and the status quo agenda can be renewed.
Take a look at the BBC coverage of the 2003 vote.
“There has been widespread support both within the European Union and in countries due to join it, for Hungary’s overwhelming vote in favour of accession to the EU. Nearly 84% of those who took part in Saturday’s referendum backed the Hungarian political parties’ pro-Europe stand – but only 46% turned out to vote…
In the end, the only thing that mattered was that the Yes vote should be at least one-quarter of the electorate. That requirement was comfortably exceeded with the vote in favour at 38%….An overwhelming vote in favour was widely expected. With the result a foregone conclusion, the silent majority simply decided it was not worth their while to turn up and vote for – or against – accession.”




![[Illustration]](http://www.mainlesson.com/books/morris/spanish/zpage146.gif)

