Who needs facts when you can just make stuff up. Vote Tory and your relatives will die in hospital.
Two things you can be sure of in life…death and taxes…and that the BBC will lie through its teeth to put Labour back in power.
OK…Three things that you can be sure of in life….
When reports about events at Stafford Hospital finally came out the BBC ducked and dived to avoid mentioning Labour’s role in the chaos in the NHS that resulted in hundreds of deaths…the BBC preferring to place the blame solely onto hospital management.
Now in the run up to an election the BBC has changed its mind about pointing the finger of blame, in fact it has gone one better, instead of just blaming the encumbent government for any deaths in the NHS they have predicted, well, speculated, that Tory reforms of the NHS will result in another ‘Stafford’ with patients dropping like flies.
The BBC’s Nick Triggle asks disengenuously…
Is another NHS scandal brewing?
Now that’s a curious opening to a report on another deadly scandal that happened under Labour’s watch. Surely the BBC’s report’s thrust should be on the actual scandal and not on sensationalist, and highly political, speculation.
What does Triggle base his speculation on? Curiously it’s on yet another report of a scandal, under Labour….and yet once again you’d be hard pushed to know that as ‘Labour’ isn’t mentioned.
You might in fact be misled into thinking this was a scandal that occured under this government on reading Triggle’s opening lines…
Lethal. Shocking. Unacceptable. Dysfunctional. Failures at every level. So said the report into maternity care at Cumbria’s Furness General Hospital.
But as was pointed out repeatedly as the inquiry published its findings on Tuesday, the parallels with Stafford Hospital are chillingly similar. In fact, Health Secretary Jeremy Hunt went as far as calling it a “second” Stafford Hospital – albeit it on a smaller scale.
Certainly it took until 2011 for the scandal to ‘break’ but it had been going on since 2004…hardly down to the Coalition you might judge….and one reason it didn’t ‘break’ was because Labour signed off on Trust status for the hospital and was told that legally the Department of Health couldn’t then intervene (page 10)…..
As the application had been deferred in 2009, rather than rejected, the Trust did not go through the quality assessment newly introduced by the DH in the aftermath of the Mid Staffordshire affair, and the DH received legal advice that it should not intervene, as the application had already received the Secretary of State’s approval in 2009.
Triggle goes on to suggest what happened could still be going on now…
In both cases it led to unnecessary suffering – and it was left to patients to expose the truth. So can we be sure this is not happening elsewhere?
Dr Bill Kirkup, the chair of the Morecambe Bay Inquiry, named after the trust which ran the hospital, admitted as such. He said “there could be elements” of what he found happening elsewhere when pressed by journalists.
But then again ‘There might not be.’ Pure speculation.
Triggle suggests a cause for the scandal…changes in the NHS…
Why? The report lists in detail a series of missed opportunities by the North West Health Authority, Care Quality Commission and Parliamentary and Health Service Ombudsman to tackle the problems at an earlier stage.
This spanned a period when the structure of regulation and monitoring was changing. Some of this was part of the constant state of revolution the NHS finds itself in, but other changes were being made in light of the Stafford Hospital scandal.
Triggle’s final paragraph slips the knife in to the hilt and makes the claim that Coalition (ie Tory) reforms to the NHS will result in similar scandals and deaths…
The NHS has just under gone one of its biggest ever reorganisations with the dismantling of regional health authorities and primary care trusts.
It begs the question: in a couple of years could we be in the same position we are now?
Must be an election coming.